Implication of analogous comparison study on Buddhist nirvana.

The analogous comparison¹ study between matterform and mindform provide some information on nirvana. In Buddhism, nirvana² mean non self. In the analogous comparison study, nirvana is found equal to zero SOEL³. Please note:

1) This is not the Buddha’s teaching. This is the author’s opinion.

2) The author has not achieved nirvana and is a layman.

3) The author SOEL entity sensor⁴ is poor.

4) This article comes from logical analysis on teachings from the Buddha⁵.

5) Use one own wisdom and decide for oneself. Use the Buddha’s Kalama sutta⁶ as a guide.

The first part logically analysed “What is nirvana?” while the second part address “Is nirvana permanent?”

Consider a person with SOEL. The SOEL entity⁷ that flow in his body neural network, setups up his mind with mental activity. His past experience in the present and past lives are contain in the SOEL entity. He has a mind with all the karma⁸ influencing his present life.

When he achieved nirvana in the present life, his present life is not over yet. He is not dead but alive. When he meditates and dwell in nirvana his SOEL is zero. Thus, his mental activity according to the analogous comparison is zero. He is in perfect equanimity, with no mental activity and no desires or aversion. For example, if he sees a sexy woman, he has no mental activity and is unaffected. He has no mental activity to possess her or engaged with her. If he has hunger pains, again he has no mental activity and no desire for food. To be alive, he must eat and drink. Such action is only possible if he is out of nirvana. He must have desire to eat or drink to perform bodily actions in eating or drinking. Eating and drinking desire is consistent with the Buddha’s 2^nd noble truth. The origin of suffering⁹.

When he came off meditation, he may desire to teach his followers and lay supporters. His SOEL is not zero but close to zero. He can go in and out of nirvana anytime he desires. He need not guard against desire in his last existence. Being still alive, his SOEL entity must flow in his body. Thus, he can have desire, such as teaching or instructing the way to nirvana.

When he died, he achieved nirvana with zero SOEL. By guarding against desire at all times, he achieved perpetual equanimity and zero SOEL. Thus, perpetual nirvana. He can’t afford a tiny desire or aversion. For that’s an instant out of nirvana or an instance of rebirth. Thus, his SOEL is equal zero or perpetual zero mental activity in nirvana.

Let say, a Buddha was scanning for SOEL entity. The Buddha have very good SOEL entity detector. He is able to read the life form SOEL entity past lives. The mental activity arising from the life form flowing SOEL allows extraction of such past lives. On achieving nirvana, before death, the flowing SOEL entity allows reading of its past life history.

After death, the SOEL entity must guard against desire at all times in perpetual equanimity, with zero SOEL or no mental activity. Thus, all SOEL entity which has achieved nirvana is alike, and cannot be distinguished. That why the Buddha never introduced or search for a certain Buddha or Arahant¹⁰ who had died. Such task was impossible and a waste of time and effort, achieving nothing¹¹.

This idea corresponds with the mathematical algebra theory that all variable is equal or alike if the value is zero, they can only be different if the variable is non-zero. Such idea is simple to the modern person who knows algebra. However, during the Buddha time in the 6^th century BC, algebra is unknown and the idea would be difficult to explain to the primitive mind.

For the second part, it is not clear whether Nirvana is permanent or not. The method is to observe SOEL entity in Nirvana for eternity and detect if the SOEL entity disappear suddenly¹². Such effort is time consuming and beyond the Buddha final lifespan and is not worthwhile.

Notes:

1. Analogous comparison study.

http://ylopin.blogspot.com/2018/03/analogous-comparison-between-matter.html

2. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nirvana_(Buddhism)

3. SOEL: self or ego level. For more information refer to analogous comparison study

http://ylopin.blogspot.com/2018/03/analogous-comparison-between-matter.html

4. SOEL entity sensor: Self or ego level entity sensor which can detect other SOEL entity. One’s SOEL sensor can be improved by practising the Buddha’s ten perfections. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paramita

5. The Buddha, having attained nirvana, means zero desire and aversion, in perfect equanimity and truthfulness naturally follows. The monks with their lifetime nirvana goal would have little desires or aversion. Naturally, they handed down the teaching with little or zero modification. The different sects of Buddhism coexisting together peacefully show that the basic teaching is nearly the same. On the contrary, for lay person with worldly desires and aversion, they are naturally prone to modify belief to suit ones wishes and desires. Thus, their holy books may suffer from modification. Also, their desire being higher than the monks may cause serious violence from their disagreement. Lastly, there is possibility of the teaching being not consistent. E.g. God help those who help themselves. Believe and be saved.

6. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kalama_Sutta

7. SOEL entity: also mindform energy or lifeform energy. Living thing consist or SOEL entity flowing in neural network of a physical matter body. Also set up one’s soul

8. on karma: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Karma_in_Buddhism

9. The degree of suffering is relative. Most feel that this trivial but in places of famine, where food is unavailable, its extreme suffering.

10. It is not known by me whether the SOEL entity in nirvana can be detected. However, the Buddha is able to tell nirvana is not annihilation, so He can detect SOEL entity in nirvana. Also, the person to whom he demonstrates may not be able to detect it.

11. Since in nirvana, the SOEL is zero, with no mental activity, thus, it is impossible to detect its past life history.

12. If the SOEL entity decides to be reborn, that is not the issue here. The issue here is the SOEL entity that chooses to be in perpetual nirvana and whether its nirvana is permanent or not. Another word for SOEL entity disappearance is annihilation after infinity time span, when the energy content of the SOEL entity is assume to decrease¹³ over time and approaches zero. If the SOEL entity energy content did not decrease, then the Buddha can answer that it is permanent. But the Buddha never says so.

13. To conform to natural cycles, that is cyclic. Otherwise accumulation of SOEL energy over infinite time as more SOEL entity achieved nirvana. That fact is not consistent with cyclic theory.