Implication of analogous comparison study on Buddhist nirvana.

The analogous comparison¹ study between matterform and mindform provide some information on nirvana. In Buddhism, nirvana² mean non self. In the analogous comparison study, nirvana is found equal to zero SOEL³. Please note:

1) This is not the Buddha’s teaching. This is the author’s opinion.

2) The author has not achieved nirvana and is a layman.

3) The author SOEL entity sensor⁴ is poor.

4) This article comes from logical analysis on teachings from the Buddha⁵.

5) Use one own wisdom and decide for oneself. Use the Buddha’s Kalama sutta⁶ as a guide.

The first part logically analysed “What is nirvana?” while the second part address “Is nirvana permanent?”

Consider a person with SOEL. The SOEL entity⁷ that flow in his body neural network, setups up his mind with mental activity. His past experience in the present and past lives are contain in the SOEL entity. He has a mind with all the karma⁸ influencing his present life.

When he achieved nirvana in the present life, his present life is not over yet. He is not dead but alive. When he meditates and dwell in nirvana his SOEL is zero. Thus, his mental activity according to the analogous comparison is zero. He is in perfect equanimity, with no mental activity and no desires or aversion. For example, if he sees a sexy woman, he has no mental activity and is unaffected. He has no mental activity to possess her or engaged with her. If he has hunger pains, again he has no mental activity and no desire for food. To be alive, he must eat and drink. Such action is only possible if he is out of nirvana. He must have desire to eat or drink to perform bodily actions in eating or drinking. Eating and drinking desire is consistent with the Buddha’s 2^nd noble truth. The origin of suffering⁹.

When he came off meditation, he may desire to teach his followers and lay supporters. His SOEL is not zero but close to zero. He can go in and out of nirvana anytime he desires. He need not guard against desire in his last existence. Being still alive, his SOEL entity must flow in his body. Thus, he can have desire, such as teaching or instructing the way to nirvana.

When he died, he achieved nirvana with zero SOEL. By guarding against desire at all times, he achieved perpetual equanimity and zero SOEL. Thus, perpetual nirvana. He can’t afford a tiny desire or aversion. For that’s an instant out of nirvana or an instance of rebirth. Thus, his SOEL is equal zero or perpetual zero mental activity in nirvana.

Let say, a Buddha was scanning for SOEL entity. The Buddha have very good SOEL entity detector. He is able to read the life form SOEL entity past lives. The mental activity arising from the life form flowing SOEL allows extraction of such past lives. On achieving nirvana, before death, the flowing SOEL entity allows reading of its past life history.

After death, the SOEL entity must guard against desire at all times in perpetual equanimity, with zero SOEL or no mental activity. Thus, all SOEL entity which has achieved nirvana is alike, and cannot be distinguished. That why the Buddha never introduced or search for a certain Buddha or Arahant¹⁰ who had died. Such task was impossible and a waste of time and effort, achieving nothing¹¹.

This idea corresponds with the mathematical algebra theory that all variable is equal or alike if the value is zero, they can only be different if the variable is non-zero. Such idea is simple to the modern person who knows algebra. However, during the Buddha time in the 6^th century BC, algebra is unknown and the idea would be difficult to explain to the primitive mind.

For the second part, it is not clear whether Nirvana is permanent or not. The method is to observe SOEL entity in Nirvana for eternity and detect if the SOEL entity disappear suddenly¹². Such effort is time consuming and beyond the Buddha final lifespan and is not worthwhile.

Notes:

1. Analogous comparison study.

http://ylopin.blogspot.com/2018/03/analogous-comparison-between-matter.html

2. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nirvana_(Buddhism)

3. SOEL: self or ego level. For more information refer to analogous comparison study

http://ylopin.blogspot.com/2018/03/analogous-comparison-between-matter.html

4. SOEL entity sensor: Self or ego level entity sensor which can detect other SOEL entity. One’s SOEL sensor can be improved by practising the Buddha’s ten perfections. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paramita

5. The Buddha, having attained nirvana, means zero desire and aversion, in perfect equanimity and truthfulness naturally follows. The monks with their lifetime nirvana goal would have little desires or aversion. Naturally, they handed down the teaching with little or zero modification. The different sects of Buddhism coexisting together peacefully show that the basic teaching is nearly the same. On the contrary, for lay person with worldly desires and aversion, they are naturally prone to modify belief to suit ones wishes and desires. Thus, their holy books may suffer from modification. Also, their desire being higher than the monks may cause serious violence from their disagreement. Lastly, there is possibility of the teaching being not consistent. E.g. God help those who help themselves. Believe and be saved.

6. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kalama_Sutta

7. SOEL entity: also mindform energy or lifeform energy. Living thing consist or SOEL entity flowing in neural network of a physical matter body. Also set up one’s soul

8. on karma: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Karma_in_Buddhism

9. The degree of suffering is relative. Most feel that this trivial but in places of famine, where food is unavailable, its extreme suffering.

10. It is not known by me whether the SOEL entity in nirvana can be detected. However, the Buddha is able to tell nirvana is not annihilation, so He can detect SOEL entity in nirvana. Also, the person to whom he demonstrates may not be able to detect it.

11. Since in nirvana, the SOEL is zero, with no mental activity, thus, it is impossible to detect its past life history.

12. If the SOEL entity decides to be reborn, that is not the issue here. The issue here is the SOEL entity that chooses to be in perpetual nirvana and whether its nirvana is permanent or not. Another word for SOEL entity disappearance is annihilation after infinity time span, when the energy content of the SOEL entity is assume to decrease¹³ over time and approaches zero. If the SOEL entity energy content did not decrease, then the Buddha can answer that it is permanent. But the Buddha never says so.

13. To conform to natural cycles, that is cyclic. Otherwise accumulation of SOEL energy over infinite time as more SOEL entity achieved nirvana. That fact is not consistent with cyclic theory.

Analogous comparison between matter domain and spiritual domain

This article describes the analogous relationship or comparison between matter domain and spiritual domain in general. The analogous comparison is not exactly science. The close analogous relationship obtained suggested the spiritual facts or data used in the comparison is likely to be true, and from these facts, a spiritual theory can be written that include these facts. The spiritual theory may not be perfect, but it will serve a framework for the theory continuous improvement.

As an example, the atomic theory in modern times is totally different from the theory first proposed.

Obviously a new standard for accepting information in the spiritual domain has to be made for the spiritual theory to progress. The present scientific standard is impossible for improvement. That’s why the spiritual domain has not seen any progress, but instead has so much conflict.

The comparison also reveals certain information lacking in the matter domain as well. The galactic big bang¹ event is a prediction coming from the comparison. This galactic big bang is the energy obtain from nuclear reaction is the result of matter being ‘dead’ or nuclear energy flow stopped when the galactic black hole at the centre of the galaxy is at absolute zero. As an example, the low momentum electron and positron collision caused the nuclear energy flow to stop as positive and negative spin to cancel each other. These remain as the author theory, as it beyond the author means to verify it.

To help your understanding of this article, the spiritual term “self or ego level” or “SOEL”² which is a measure of a person selfishness degree is introduced. Its relationship to mental activity is discussed. The higher the person SOEL, the higher is the mental activity.

At birth, the SOEL entity got bonded to the person body and flow in the brain neural network. Once bonded, the powerful SOEL entity is constrained by the physical body and its neural network, and the SOEL entity special powers become dormant. Its previous life history is thus forgotten. However, although dormant, the accumulation of his dormant past life experiences will influence whatever decision, choices and disposition make in the new life.

After birth, the person is just a few cells with almost zero SOEL. Its mental activity is also low. As the person grow and become a baby and goes through teenager to adults, its SOEL generally increased.

A person SOEL level increases when he gain things such as materialistic assets, possession, achievements and new relationship make new social network, or having new relationship e.g. a wife a son, etc. etc. Once gain, these things become part of his SOEL and increment generally result in mundane happiness.

Likewise a person SOEL can be reduced, when things dear to him, are lost or stolen or criticized, much suffering is caused by the reduction. The higher the gain, the higher the mundane happiness, the higher the reduction, the severe is the sufferring³.

At death, the person body cells will decrease to zero and his SOEL will reached momentarily zero. The reduction of the SOEL level caused so much suffering at death.

When SOEL is momentarily zero, the SOEL entity disbond from the physical body, and left the dying physical body. Typically, after death, the SOEL entity cannot on its own maintain SOEL at 0 for long time, and depending on its SOEL, it will be reborn at the planes of existence corresponding to its SOEL⁴.

The first analogous comparison is temperature in the matter domain versus SOEL in the spiritual domain. The temperature is the quantifiable measure of internal motion of the particles, whereas SOEL is a non quantifiable measure of mental activity. The motion of particles is in three dimensions in space, whereas the mental activity may be in a number of dimension⁵.

Motion is govern by Newton’s law in the matter domain. Mental activity is governed by the karmic law, so Newton’s 3^rd Law is analogous to the law of Karma⁶.

The karmic effect of killing an holy man is worse than killing an animal. The holy man SOEL and mental activity is low, analogous to a fixed wall. Killing a holy man is thus analogous to the collision of a car with a fixed wall. The collision cause temperature increment and the car and deformation due to momentum absorbed. The spiritual domain is the increase in the killer SOEL,

which brings him a woeful plane of existence at death.

Newton 2^nd Law is F = mass X acceleration. Since the mass of the person SOEL entity is zero⁷, the analogous effect is the mental activity speed can be extremely fast. When the person SOEL entity is released either through special power achievement or near death experience, the travel speed is also extremely fast⁸.

Newton first law of motion is also known as the law of inertia. It appears that this law has no analogous effect as the mass of SOEL entity is zero⁷.

States of matter depends on temperature of matter, thus, analogous to the spiritual planes of existence⁴.

At very low temperature close to zero, certain matter achieved superconductivity or superfluidity. This is analogous to special powers achieved by certain person whose SOEL is low or close to zero⁹.

For high temperature superconductivity, for example, hydrogen sulphide is achieved by high compression. The person whose SOEL is high can achieve such special powers if and only if he practise meditation, an activity that reduced mental activity⁹.

When matter becomes non matter, it can be consider the death of matter¹⁰ and nuclear energy is released. The analogous event in the spiritual dimension is death at the point when a person SOEL is at zero. I.e. The point the SOEL entity left the dying physical body. I.e. The nuclear energy liberation is analogous to the SOEL entity liberation¹¹.

Nuclear energy liberation is an explosive event which corresponds to SOEL equal to zero. I.e. SOEL equal to zero is analogous to absolute zero temperature. In the universe, the location where the temperature is close to absolute zero is the supermassive black hole at the galactic centre. As the galaxy goes through compressive cycle¹, the temperature of the galactic centre gets closer to absolute zero. At absolute 0 temperature, a galactic big bang is predicted to happen¹.

Matter based sensors can do the job of measurement if the noise is below the signal level. Many matter based sensors can be constructed and used in measurement and the sensors are shareable. In contrast to the spiritual domain, every person has an SOEL entity which acts as spiritual sensor¹¹ in the spiritual domain. It is absolutely impossible to share spiritual detector. Here, the matter based sensor noise is analogous to the noise in his spiritual detector, the mental activity level¹².

The close analogy, suggested that the fundamental item in the universe is electromagnetic radiation and not mass. Perhaps SOEL entity fundamental item is also electromagnetic radiation, but at this time not much is known about the nature of SOEL entity.

1. http://ylopin.blogspot.my/2018/03/observational-evidence-for-galactic-big_28.html

2. http://ylopin.blogspot.my/2016/08/karma-and-concept-of-self-or-ego-level.html

3. Appears to be action of karma, with mundane happiness and increase in SOEL. Higher SOEL if the action is evil such as stealing, killing, or instructs others to do evil actions. For lower SOEL, good deeds such as giving, compassion are done, consistent with karmic law.

4. The higher SOEL at death, the mental activity show greater suffering such as worry, anger, etc. etc. He will appear (born) in the plane of existence, where such mental activity exists commonly. Contrast to matter, e.g. water commonly exists as a liquid when temperature lies between 0 and 100C at atmospheric pressure.

5. Not much is known about the mind at this time. Since nirvana is equal to SOEL zero, (author’s opinion) and Buddhahood is a special instance of nirvana, we expect the training needed to achieve it, to be mental dimension. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paramita

6. Newton 3^rd Law for every action, there is an equal but opposite direction. This is analogous to law of karma. Simply, meant doing a bad deed, getting all the bad consequence of a bad deed. Since the mental activity is multi dimensional, the consequence may not be in different forms. E.g. Violence may not always lead to violence, but lead to increase in SOEL level.

7. If person before dying, (with SOEL entity flowing) is weighed, his weight before death and after death is the same. This suggested the mass of SOEL entity is close to zero.

8. SOEL entity is possible to have speed at infinity, whether there is a light speed limit or not known.

9. A person whose SOEL is very low is able to attain special powers (Rddhi) wherever he wants, whenever he wants and for as long as he wants. This statement follows from the fact that special powers (Rddhi) comes from having attain dhyana. Reference to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rddhi

and https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dhyana_in_Buddhism

See under "In Theravada" under subheader "Gradual development".

10. All matter obeys Mass–energy equivalence.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mass-energy_equivalence

It can be consider that the energy flow in matter that set up its behaviour as matter is almost permanent. The death of matter is when the energy flow which set up the matter properties, stop. Note also the computer processing is ‘dead’ when the electrical energy stops flowing in the computer electronic circuits.

11. The liberation from its dying physical body caused SOEL entity to become powerful. It has all the Rddhi powers Refer to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rddhi

However, just one instant of wrong mental activity, the SOEL entity will be bonded in a new life in the plane of existence corresponding to its SOEL.

12. Nuclear energy liberated, is an explosive event, remain free energy and do not become matter back. This correspond to the SOEL entity having SOEL zero for long time. Such condition is described by the Buddhist as nirvana, the ultimate in mental equanimity and serenity. It’s described as non self, no self, lack of any self. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nirvana (under Buddhism, 2^nd last paragraph)

13. Non sharable sensors lead to situation same as colour blindness. Here more people can see colours, so a colour blind person is forced to accept colours. However, most people have spiritual sensor with poor detectors. Thus, the spiritual concept is difficult to accept. The internet helps in this area, though small, the cumulative SOEL entity detection experience, build up over time. An example in near death experience, the liberated SOEL entity can detect any person, read his thoughts and verbal communication.

14. To improve the detection capability of one own SOEL entity which is bonded to his physical body, he must practise meditation and obtain dhyana.

Observational evidence for Galactic Big Bang rev 2

Previously, I write about the proposal for a galactic big bang theory. The galactic big bang theory is formulated from the out of the box thinking about the analogous comparison¹ between spiritual life and matter. This article presents the evidences or observations which support the case of the galactic big bang from a galactic black hole.

The symmetrical Fermi bubbles in our Milky Way on both sides of the Milky Way galaxy looks like a minute burp or mild explosion from the galaxy black hole. The bubbles look so uniform or symmetrical² all the way across the galaxy black hole (GBH). A more powerful explosion from the GBH, is the galactic jet which is also symmetrical².

If there are Fermi bubble and galactic jets, a massive galactic big bang is also likely. As the nature of matter distributed in black hole is symmetrical², the massive expulsion of matter from the galactic black hole is most likely symmetrical.

The massive expulsion of matter coupled with the sudden huge gravity reduction, provides momentum to reach the outer edges of the galaxy to form galactic bar³ and spiral arms⁴.

Secondary explosion can happen after the ejected matter moves out of the black hole. Without severe compression, massive particles become unstable and decomposed into lighter particles giving off energy. The decompression of the matter can also absorb heat energy causing some spots to be at absolute temperature causing secondary burst of energy. This secondary explosion is observed as supernovae explosion.

I.e. Many of the galaxies shapes are the results of massive galactic big bangs of the past. i.e. There are many galactic big bangs in the past and there will be many more in the future. i.e. This is an endless cycle⁵ of galactic big bang followed by galactic expansion and finally galactic contraction with no beginning and no ending.

In my previous article⁹, I mention that after big bang, the expansion cycle started and stop, followed by contraction. The evidence for contraction is in the absence of ‘x’ galaxy plane shape. The previous galaxy plane before galactic big bang must contract fully towards the GBH, otherwise the intersecting ‘x’ shape planes with spiral arms will be created.

Indirect proof of energy generation in black hole.

The Large Hadron Collider (LHC) is the world's largest and most powerful particle collider. Energy (gamma ray) can be generated from LHC collision experiments. At the time instant at the moment of collision, the particles are going through impulsive high compressive stress at a single spot where the particle collided.

For galactic black hole, matter as particles, are going through continuously and severe compressive stress all around the particle. The compressive stress in the galactic black hole is much higher than that could be achieved by the LHC. If LHC can generate gamma rays, it follows that the galactic black hole should be able to generate gamma ray. For galactic black hole to generate huge energy release in a galactic big bang, lots of particles or massive particles⁶ must suddenly become free energy. This can happen when the GBH has been contracted to a single spot or a small area.

Why don’t we often see burst of energy from the GBH?

This part is speculation and there may be better explanations.

Like a super volcano that erupts once after a long hibernation, burst of energy from a black hole is not visible because the energy is trapped and absorbed by matter as particles.

Evidence supporting galactic big bang, is the detection of high gamma ray explosion for few hours in a spot empty of stars, clouds of gas, visible objects or radio sources. An example is the detection of gamma ray burst of at least 94 GeV. (GRB 130427A)¹⁰  Refer to the web page below. https://www.nasa.gov/topics/universe/features/shocking-burst.html

The god particle (aka Higgs boson) and other massive particles suggested that the severe compression at the centre of the super massive black hole can produce massive particles than what we known in particle physics.

As the actual observation and theory tie in nicely together, it follows that the galactic big bang is more likely to be correct than the concept of a big bang in the single spot at the time zero¹¹ .

Notes

1. An example of the analogous comparison which I found after sending the article about galactic big bang by email.

Living things e.g. animals and human beings are alive because there are energy flowing in neural network. If the energy flow stop, we say the living things are dead. In contrast with matter for the simple case of electron and positron collision at low speed, matter is ‘dead’ when energy flow stop and gamma ray is liberated.

For the computer case, when energy is flowing in the CPU, the computer is alive or doing processing. If the computer is switched off, the energy flow in the CPU stop, the computer is dead and the energy flow is dissipated as heat energy.

2. Why symmetrical galactic burp or burst or jet?

The symmetrical explosion strongly suggested that the nature of matter distributed in or around black hole is most likely symmetrical. This symmetrical nature can be explained by the following statements in this paragraph. Matter as in the stars, planets, planetoid, asteroids, comets, meteors and etc. consisting of elements and compounds, previously orbit around the super massive black hole. As the galaxy contracts, more matter will be captured by the super massive black hole. The spin⁷ of the matter captured by the super massive black hole will soon stop or dissipated away. However the orbit around super massive black hole along the galactic plane will still continue although the speed is reduced. This reduction of speed happened as matter is crushed to become particles (a state of matter only possible in a black hole). This is the way matter can exist in or near the super massive black hole in order to occupy a small space. Note: Matter is chiefly empty space. Matter as particles, thus, orbit around the GBH. As the galactic black hole occupies a small spot or area, it will make many revolutions⁷ around the centre of the GBH. These revolutions cause matter as particles to be distributed uniformly or symmetrically in a super massive black hole.

3. How galactic bar is formed.

When galactic big bang occur, the lightest matter e.g. particles or hydrogen gas will shoot out from the GBH at the maximum speed. The most massive bodies will move out at the minimum speed from the GBH. In between the lightest and the massive bodies, the ejected speed ranges from the maximum speed to the minimum speed. After many years, the ejected matter spread continuously from a bar coming out of GBH right up to the spiral arms.

4. How spiral arms are formed

The small speed spread among the matter ejected will lead to the formation of a spiral arm of the galaxy. Due to the symmetry of the galactic big bang, the formation of spiral arm is also symmetrical.

If there are more spiral arms, they will also be symmetrical. The different spiral arms are due to the ejected speed being much different apart.

But if we consider only one of the spiral arms, the speed spread is relatively close together.

5. At each big bang cycles, matter as particles will be converted to energy. I.e. After infinite number of big bangs cycles, matter in a galactic black hole will be substantially reduced. Eventually all galaxies will run out of matter. This is not possible to support endless big bang cycles if the reduction in matter is not replaced. Here I proposed that electromagnetic wave is being absorbed by the galactic black holes to form particles with mass. After all light can be consider mass particle with extremely low mass. These extremely low mass particles will soon become massive particles in a galactic black hole.

6. If the LHC can form heavier particles after collision, a galactic black hole surely can form massive particle.

7. The matter bodies which are captured by the galactic black hole have the orbital movement around the galactic black hole and the spin around the axis of the matter bodies. The spin can be resolve in two components:

a) along the galactic plane parallel to the orbital movement. This component alternates

between reinforce and against the orbital movement. When it is against the orbital

movement it will dissipates away.

b) orthogonal to the galactic plane perpendicular to the orbital movement. This component

move closer to the black hole and then attempt to move vertically inside the galactic plane

and then move further from the galactic black hole. The last two movement encounter

resistance and will dissipates away.

8. Why objects spin?

Matter as particles, spin or orbit about the centre of the super massive black hole in a plane before big bang. After the galactic big bang, matter is ejected from the black hole. Since, it is spinning previously, the ejected matter bodies will continue to spin. Whether spin clockwise or anti clockwise depends on the ejected bodies are inverted or not. There may be collision when ejected out of the GBH, so the rotation speed can also be zero.

9. Refer to Galactic Big Bang Rev 3

10.  Probably not a galactic big bang. The time span is extremely long for a galactic life cycle. At this time moment, we probably have not come across any galactic big bang. However, this observation provides evidence of existence of supermassive particles.

11. The current accepted theory is the initial big bang at a single spot giving rise to the galaxies we see today, is flawed. Reason:

a) For such big bang, the power is tremendous and the energy needed is extremely large to move matter from a spot to the extreme edge of the universe and become planar  galaxies.  Such extreme power and energy is extremely difficult to control. and impossible to happen in nature. See 11(c)

b) Galaxies at the edge of the universe are extremely old, double the light years as age. Over such extremely long age, lots of matter would have converted to light energy. There should be differences between galaxies nearby and edges of the universe, since old galaxies should have lost significant amount of mass. However, no report on differences was found.

c) Initial big bang is in line with the concept God created the world and probably control the explosive  big bang. A very convenient answer to leave everything to God.

Theory of mind formation base on beings with matter base bodies e.g. animals and human beings.

In the universe, there are two aspects, one is matter formation and the other is life formation or mind formation. Much is known about science of matter, but little is known about life formation. This is because there are various matter based sensors or detectors which are able to obtain information about the matter body. Matter based sensors or detectors do not detect life formation in general. If the life formation have matter bodies, as in the case of animals or human, matter based detectors can detect their matter bodies. E.g. the optical camera or biological eye can detect the animals or a human being.

Matter on the micro¹ scale consists of particles flow which is random particle motion. The particles themselves are actually almost permanent electromagnetic energy flow which is setup as nuclear energy. Einstein equation E=mc² show the equivalence between matter content (i.e. mass) and energy. This equation holds true for matter in both macro and micro scale. The matterform energy is the permanent electromagnetic energy flow in matter.

Life formation in the human body also consists of energy flow through matter based brain neural network. This energy flow allow the setup of the mind which is related to the person self or ego level. This energy flow can also be referring to as mindform energy or mental energy or the mind.

Animals also have the same energy flow except their matter based brain neural network consist of less neuron than human; therefore, their processing capability is impaired. Thus, life formation is some sort of a bond between the material human body and the mindform energy. I.e. Each life form has its own mindform energy. All animals and humans has a death process which the mindform energy stop flowing and leave their matter based body. Their matter based body become non living thing and are subject to decay and decomposition.

This life formation can be analogously compared to a computer which is energy flowing in the electronic circuits. The processing capability of the computer in general depends on the circuit nodes or circuit complexity. Switching off the computer, the energy flow stop, the computer processing stop, and heat energy is liberated.

In contrast, life form is considered dead when the energy flow or mindform energy flow stop in the matter based brain neural network. The reported reincarnation experience and study by Prof Ian Stevenson suggested that there is some sort continuity between the previous life and the next reincarnated life. After reincarnation, the mindform energy flow in the new reincarnated body, thus suggesting some sort of permanency setup of this mindform energy flow analogous to matter energy flow. The reincarnated person has the capacity to recall his previous life through this mindform energy only if he has developed the capability. I.e. there is memory stored in this mindform energy flow, an infinite store of past life experiences.

The difficulty of writing this article on analogous comparison between matterform and mindform energy is that not much is known about mindform. This is because matter based sensors do not detect mindform energy. Mindform energy can only be detected by one’s own mindform energy in the same mind domain. Each life form has its own mindform energy. It has to use its own mindform energy to detect. The detection capability of each own mindform energy is very different. Animals and human beings are mindform energy bonded to biological matter body, so their ability to detect mindform domain is impaired. Most people have very poor detection. However, very few people have developed the capability to detect. Unfortunately, they can’t be shared or borrow just the way matterform sensor can be shared or build or used in getting reproducible results.

As I do not have the capability to detect mindform energy, I have to base on what is reported on the internet. Also, the possibility of reported information being incorrect further complicates matters. Nevertheless, it is the only way of getting the information, and the information can be subjected to consistency check. One person stands out in providing information. He was Prince Siddharta who lived in the 6th century BC, the founder of Buddhism and is known as a Buddha. The Buddha, himself claim to have six higher knowledge or power. (Abhijna)² such as Iddhi³, telepathy, super-hearing, divine seeing, and seeing past lives. In this article, what matters is the Buddha omniscence⁴ capability.

Prince Siddharta background from being a prince to an ascetic to the Buddha suggested that

a) He has no material ulterior motives

b) He has no interest in power and influence

c) His only motives is to teach the way (i) to nirvana for monks and

(ii) to a happy layman life for laymen.

The Buddha 4th precepts for layman is

I undertake the rule of training which consists in abstention from false speech

Therefore it is unlikely that his own claim is false, as this precept also apply to the monks, arahats and the Buddha. The arahats and the Buddha are fully enlightened (nirvana). They are in the state of non-self or zero self. They have absolutely no craving, no desire or aversion and in perfect equanimity. Thus, with no ulterior motive to tell a lie, therefore only told the truth.

The mind is higher than matter. Mind can control matter, i.e. Ghosts do not have matter bodies, so generally matter based detectors do not detect them. However there are cases of ghost being detected by matter based sensors. Such cases are probably due to the ghost mindform energy creating a matter based ghostly apparition. [For example, in some cases, ghosts can be detected by matter based sensors only if the mind of the ghost will or enable the detection of ghostly apparition.]

In reincarnation, it was reported that persons who suffered a violent death such as getting shot or being stabbed was born with birth marks in his next reincarnated life. The location of the birth mark exactly correspond to where he was shot or stabbed in his past life body.⁵ A possible explanation of the birth mark is the mind occupation on the spot before death. In the next life, the marks are formed from the continuation of the mind to dwell at the spot.

A Buddhist monk was reported to have many instances of his body in monanstery.³ His mind must have willed the duplication of his body. Obviously there was only one real body and the others were creation out from air.

The above is the short description of the theory of life formation. It is theory, since none of it can be scientifically proven through matter based sensors.

Thus, the first analogous comparison between matter formation and life formation is matterform energy flow and mindform energy flow.

The difference between matterform energy and mindform energy flow is yet to be discovered, but the operative nature of mindform energy flow is in different domain of which the exact nature remain to be discovered. Perhaps by comparing analogously between matter and life, some information could be revealed. However, the mindform domain is very different from matter domain, and it is expected to have some differences. One can see that matter based sciences is quantifiable while mindform domain science is still primitive and not quantifiable.

What aspect to start the comparison? For matter, temperature is used and the effect on external (macro level) and internal motion (micro level). For life formation, self or ego level and its relation on mental activity is compared. For matter, it is well known that temperature is a measure of internal motion. For life, the analogous statement is self or ego level is an abstract indication of mental activity. When a person has a very strong self or ego, it can be said that he is selfish, and he has many desires and aversions. He will be thinking how to achieve his desires and to prevent aversions from happening. He may be expressing, cursing, angry and worry if his desire is not achieved or his aversions keep on happening. He may plan or do evil deeds such as murder, stealing or corruption just to achieve his desires or prevent his aversions from happening. Day to day, there will be many mental objects and activity happening in his mind. I.e., the stronger, the self or ego level, the stronger is the mental activity. Concentration level is the ability to do a single mental object and focus at it at all time. Thus, when mental activity increases concentration level decreases. This is the second analogous comparison between matter and life – temperature versus self or ego level.

The next analogous comparison is the about the sensing capability of one own mindform energy to detect other mindform energy. Those with higher self or ego level generally have higher mental activity. This activity is unrelated to sensing other mindform energy. They are analogous to noise in matterform sensors. Should the noise be higher than signal in matterform sensor, detection is not possible. For mindform sensors to be capable, the right mental activity must be higher than other irrelevant mental activity or noise. Such mental activity process is also known as concentration meditation.

Some matter exhibit superconductivity and super fluidity at temperature close to zero. These correspond to low mental activity or low ego or self level close to zero. At that ego or self level, some human beings may possess special powers. These jhana special powers are

a) Can travel thro matter. Pass through walls, earth as if flying at the very high speed, e.g. light speed, through the air.⁶

b) Can interact with matter⁷.

c) Can read other mindform energy⁸ thoughts, feelings and speech.

In near death experience, the mindform energy is weakly bonded to the body and may left the body. The mindform energy is able to travel through matter. However, it can only read other human beings interactions, feel emotions and thoughts, and the voice communications between human beings. This is not done through one’s own dying matter body but by tapping and reading the mindform energy of others. However the ability of the mindform energy to communicate with others is not possible, simply because the others have poor read or detection capability of mindform energy, and they read and understand through their matter bodies sense organs. For interaction with matter, it is not known to be capable.

For matter with high temperature superconductivity such as hydrogen sulphide⁹ gas, this is analogous to special powers in mindform with much higher self or ego level. For such mindform, the above special powers can develop when the concentration power is high enough. However, such mindform or person must practice concentration meditation to increase concentration level. To see how this can happen with concentration, let’s consider the ideal gas law equations on the matter domain. The ideal Gas Law equation PV = RT, where P is pressure, V is volume, R a constant, T is temperature is in matter domain. The counterpart in life form domain could not be quantified and represented by equations. However the meaning and relation between parameters can be discovered. The mental concentration acting on the container or spread of mental activity is related to the self or ego level of the person. The above relationship happen to hold true for a person with higher self or ego level to achieve jhana special powers is that he must do concentration meditation¹⁰.

Matter has states such as particle, solid, liquid, gases, plasma depend on its temperature. Life also has states of existence depend on the ego or self level. These states of existence are the six sensory planes; follow by planes beyond the sensory planes. Animals and Humans are planes with matter bodies bonded to their mindform energy. The sensory beings in order of the reducing ego or self level are Hell beings, ghost, demon, animals, human beings and heavenly beings. Hell beings are thus, have the highest ego or self level. Animals and human being are the only sensory life form with matter bodies. States of matter is thus analogous to planes of existence.

In matter domain, the Newton’s law of motion is obeyed. For whatever action force there is a reaction force. If a matter object is applied a force, there is a reaction force on the applicator. The 1st and 3rd law is analogous to the law of karma. Generally, a person who punches another person will get a punch back from the other person.

However, the person who punches a holy man will not get a punch back. It appears that the law of karma failed to work. But according to the Buddha, the karma works because the person who punch the holy man, will pay for his wicked deed next time, when his karma matures, e.g. life in woeful states e.g. hell. The holy man is analogous to a fixed concrete wall. The person who punches is analogous to a vehicle travelling and collided with the fixed concrete wall. After collision, the vehicle is deformed because the effect of the collision is transfer to the micro scale of the atomic particles of the vehicle, causing the vehicle to be deformed. The person who punch the holy man; because of his act; his ego or self level will increase on the micro scale; thus, should he died; his future life will be in lower planes of existence.

Consider a suicide bomber who sacrifices his life to kill innocent victims. He does his act out of out of ignorance or mistaken belief in rewards or promoting a cause favourable to his group. Some victims after being killed; develop hatred towards the suicide bomber. Because of hatred, these victims and the suicide bomber will be reborn in woeful states of existences and continue fighting. In the human plane of existence there are laws and system to prevent endless fight. But in the woeful state of existence, there is no such law or system. So the suicide bomber will be fighting against many of the victims and suffer endless blows. A similar situation is one who triggers and orders the detonation of the nuclear bomb. 

The second law, Force = mass X acceleration, however, seem inapplicable to mind domain. Perhaps, the Force is analogous to the mental activity of the mind will to travel. The mass in the matter domain appear not to have any analogous in the mind domain, because whatever the analogous item in the mind domain its value is either zero or extremely small, almost zero. Thus, the mind may travel at a maximum speed limit, just like the speed of light in matter domain or no speed limit. The maxmum speed or whether there is a speed limit remains to be discovered in the future.

Matter can go through nuclear reaction, generating energy. An example is the annihilation of electron and positron generating energy. An electron has the same mass with positron but opposite spin. When low momentum electron collided with low momentum positron, there is a high possibility the spin cancelled out and matterform energy flow is stopped. This is analogous to mindform energy flow stopped at the moment of death, and mindform energy is liberated. I.e. ‘Death of matter’ or purely electromagnetic energy liberation is analogous to momentarily nirvana at the moment of death. Clearly, nirvana in life form is analogous to nuclear reaction in matter. For, matter based bodies such as the stars or the sun in our solar system, they goes through nuclear reaction to generate energy. This is analogous to nirvana, an event achieved in a human lifetime before death.

When light energy liberate from matter in a star nuclear reaction, it travel at the speed of light. The analogous in mindform domain is the capability of mindform energy to travel from slow speed to extremely fast as in a single thought moment. This experience has been described in near death experiences. The Buddha also has described the speed as a flash of lightning which represent the speed of light. The alternative description would be thunder which would be slower and is the speed of sound. However this description was not used.

Thus liberation of energy in matter is analogous to the nirvana state in spiritual life. Nirvana is a state where desires or aversions are ended or no desires and no aversions. It is also a state of non self or no ego or self level. It is the absolute zero of ego or self level in perfect equanimity. This is analogous to matter temperature at absolute zero. In the universe, the temperature close to absolute zero is the galactic black hole or the intergalactic space. As the intergalactic space is mostly empty, it is unlikely to go down to temperature at absolute zero. The more massive the galactic black hole, the closer to the temperature to absolute zero. Since nirvana is analogous to matterform energy liberation, when portion of the galactic black hole temperature is absolute zero, a big bang is predicted. As the portion of the GBH at absolute zero can varies from minute to massive, a galactic minute burp, galactic jet ranges to galactic big bang is predicted. The galactic burp and galactic jet has been confirmed in observation. As the mass of the particle in the Galactic black hole can ranges from simple particle like electron to massive particle i.e. gamma rays from MeV to TeV ranges can be emitted in a galactic big bang. After the galactic big bang, matter as particles undergoes decompression causing particles to become lighter. The decompression will require energy and the temperature may again be at absolute zero causing a secondary explosion.

A write up on the galactic big bang is found listed below.

1. http://ylopin.blogspot.my/2016/11/galactic-big-bang-rev-3.html or

2. http://www.thephysicsmill.com/2015/06/14/speculative-sunday-can-a-black-hole-explode/

Comment (Yin) on Nov 14 2016

3. http://ylopin.blogspot.my/2017/02/observational-evidence-for-galactic-big.html

4. http://www.thephysicsmill.com/2015/06/14/speculative-sunday-can-a-black-hole-explode/

Comment (Yin) on Feb 8 2017

For more analogous comparison between matterform and mindform please refer to

http:

http://ylopin.blogspot.my/2016/05/comparison-between-matterform-and.html

http://ylopin.blogspot.my/2016/08/karma-and-concept-of-self-or-ego-level.html

Having done the analogous comparison, the objective of matter is to provide energy to sustain life. The mindform energy, however, is to set up the mind, so that living beings roam the universe. The built in karma and the planes of existence provide a fair and just automatic punishing and reward system. Those, who aim for nirvana, has to go through effort to reduce self or ego level and achieve ultimate serenity, which is the objective for Buddhist monks.

Lastly as matter and life are actually consisting of energy flow, it would make sense if electromagnetic energy is a fundamental object, while mass is derived quantity. 

Notes:

1. Macro scale is the zoom level which is what our eyes see or detect. Micro level is the zoom level where its particles can be observed.

2. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Miracles_of_Gautama_Buddha

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abhijna

Abhijñā from Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

3. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iddhi

Ṛddhi From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia (Redirected from Iddhi)

An example of near death experiences has been reported to match the Buddha concept of iddhi is the case of Anita Moorjani. http://www.nderf.org/Experiences/1anita_m_nde.html

Consistency is also shown in the Buddhist text on iddhi.

3.a ...... At that moment Cula Panthaka said to himself, “My brother says, ‘There are no monks in the monastery.’ I will show him that there are monks in the monastery.” And forthwith he filled the whole mango grove with monks. Some of them were making robes, others were dyeing robes, others were repeating the sacred texts. Thus did Cula Panthaka create by supernormal power a thousand monks, each different from every other. So when Jivaka’s messenger saw the numerous monks, he returned and told Jivaka, “Noble sir, the entire mango grove is full of monks.” And right there the Elder Cula Panthaka did as follows:

Panthaka, multiplying himself a thousandfold,

Sat in the charming mango grove until he was sent for.

The Teacher said to the man, “Go to the monastery and say, ‘The Teacher summons Cula Panthaka.’ ” The man went and said what he was told to say. Thereupon the cry went up from a thousand throats, “I am Cula Panthaka! I am Cula Panthaka!” The man returned and said, “Reverend sir, they all say they are Cula Panthaka.” Said the Teacher, “Well then, go and take by the hand the first monk that says, ‘I am Cula Panthaka,’ and the rest will disappear.” The man did so. Immediately the thousand monks disappeared. The Elder Cula Panthaka returned with the man who came for him.

http://www.bps.lk/olib/wh/wh354-p.html#45TheElderCaPanthaka

Note: The text suggested the ability of Cula Panthaka to teleport himself to the first one that the man hold and the thousand of his created monks disappeared. This is very difficult to accept in modern times because such event has never occur again. For any ordinary person, such event is absolutely impossible. But in front of many people and the buddha, a lie would have been found out and the text would not be recorded as in the holy text. Moreover, the text is also consistent in other events mentioned by the holy text, such as given below. (3b, 3c and 3d)

b Some monks came to see the Buddha and, hearing the Dhamma attained Arahantship with psychic powers. Later, they departed flying through the air. The Venerable Ananda, who had seen them coming, noticed their absence and inquired of the Buddha where they had gone. Just at that moment some swans flew through the air. Then the Buddha remarked that Arahants, who possess psychic powers, go through the air like swans. Dhammapada verse 13

http://www.metta.lk/english/Narada/13-Loka%20Vagga.htm#N10

c The Buddha daily routine. Scan the world if he could render any help to anyone in the nirvana goal. Appear and teach the dharmma.

d Miracle of Psychic Power

He can split himself into many "self-bodies" and become one. He appears and vanishes. He can go unimpeded through walls, ramparts, and mountains as if through space. He dives in and out of the earth as if it were water. He walks on water as if it were dry land. Sitting cross- legged he flies through the air like a bird. His mind-made body can travel as far as the Brahma world (Astral travel). With his hand he can touch even the sun and moon, so mighty and powerful.

Digha Nikaya 11,

http://www.suttas.com/dn-11-kevaddha-sutta-what-brahma-didnt-know.html

4. https://www.accesstoinsight.org/tipitaka/sn/sn56/sn56.031.wlsh.html

Simsapa Sutta: The Simsapa Leaves translated from the Pali by Maurice O'Connell Walshe

The Buddha omniscience capability is consistent with the concept of infinite past lives in different world systems and his six higher knowledges or power. Knowledge from the past lives, especially those corresponding to the time age of science, technology can be obtained. The use of earth, water, air and fire element as the solid, liquid, gases and temperature and the concept of the nanosecond time duration in modern times, as the flash of lightning indicate his awareness of modern science.

5. Birthmarks and Birth Defects Corresponding to Wounds on Deceased Persons Dr. Ian Stevenson. Journal of Scientific Exploration, Vol. 7, No. 4, pp. 403-410, 1993

6. See note 3. This also has been described in certain near death experience, when the mindform energy left the dying body and performing the special power.

7. See note 3. The ability of replicate and project bodily images of oneself is mental interaction with matter, mind control over matter. I.e. Mind higher than matter.

8. See note 3. The mind reader. Communication mind to mind is only possible if the other mindform energy also have the jhana special powers. This is observed in certain near death experiences where the mindform energy leaves the dying body and performing the mind reader.

9. https://www.sciencealert.com/hydrogen-sulphide-smashes-superconductor-temperature-record

Hydrogen Sulphide Smashes Superconductor Temperature Record 

10. https://www.urbandharma.org/pdf/TheJhanas.pdf

The Jhanas in Theravada Buddhist Meditation.

https://books.google.com.my/books?isbn=8120808711